What’s the worst news you could receive after completing a three-year, $968 million renovation on your current arena? That it will have to be moved in ten years in order to update a major commuter rail hub that sits below it.
Well, that’s exactly what happened to the historic Madison Square Garden earlier today.
The New York City Council voted 47-1 to extend the Garden’s operating permit for ten more years. The Garden’s ownership had asked for it to be in perpetuity while the Bloomberg administration had hoped for a 15 year permit. Why a ten year permit then? The Council feels that it would be an adequate amount of time for the Garden to find a new location within the city.
This is all coming to fruition due to a plan to expand Pennsylvania station which sits just below Madison Square Garden. The commuter station is the busiest in North America, serving over 500,000 people a day. They not only hope to ease the congestion but they also want to redevelop the surrounding neighborhoods as well.
This isn’t the first time such a thing has been planned for Madison Square Garden. Prior to the 2008 renovation of the Garden there was a $14 billion plan in place to move the arena and transform the station below it. That effort was crippled by a recession.

About Adam Stafki
Recent Posts
Kyler Murray has a secret weapon and he knows it
On Tuesday, the Minnesota Vikings officially named Kyler Murray their starting quarterback as he beat out J.J. McCarthy...
J.J. McCarthy had classy message after losing Vikings starting job
On Wednesday, the Minnesota Vikings made their quarterback decision, naming Kyler Murray the starting quarterback over J.J. McCarthy....
Aaron Rodgers directly refutes new head coach
"It's not real football."
Raiders taking unique approach with Fernando Mendoza
The Las Vegas Raiders made Indiana Hoosiers standout Fernando Mendoza the No. 1 overall pick in the 2026...
Coach Jeff Hafley issues a warning to running back De’Von Achane
The Miami Dolphins offense was always going to look a lot different this year with Jaff Hafley taking...
Bills Simmons calls on WNBA to fire commissioner
"They have to fix this, and I hope they do."