EA Sports invited a bunch of NFL rookies to guess their rating in the upcoming Madden 16.
Most of the players guessed that they’d be placed in the eighties (Jameis Winston estimated 84 or 82, Amari Cooper placed himself at 86, while Marcus Mariota guessed that he’d get an 80) although the Colts’ Phillip Dorsett confidently gave himself a rating of 95.
EA recorded the players’ reactions to seeing their Madden rating for the first time. Needless to say, while some were happy, skepticism seemed to be the predominant response among the NFL rooks.
Per EA Sports’ own ratings, here are the top ten rookies in Madden 16.
10. Vic Beasley – 77
9. Marcus Mariota – 78
9. Kevin White – 78
9. Melvin Gordon – 78
6. Dante Fowler – 79
5. Brandon Scherff – 80
5. Leonard Williams – 80
5. Todd Gurley – 80
2. Jameis Winston – 81 (Winston’s guess really was pretty accurate)
1. Amari Cooper – 82
Judging by this list, Dorsett has a long way to go to get that coveted 95 rating.

About Ryan Wong
Recent Posts
Jaelan Phillips looking to produce at high level in 2026
"I'm excited about expanding my game."
UCLA quarterfinals win proves costly
"My concern is for him and his career."
Mike Tomlin makes first public comments since stepping down
“It's been an honor.'
Caitlin Clark shines in return to the court
“I was really just excited."
Cal Raleigh responds to Randy Arozarena: ‘no beef’
"I love Randy, I do."
Miami University aims to be ‘best Group of Six program in the country’
"Our goal is to be the best Group of Six program in the country."