Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow (9) looks on during a press conference after at the IEL Indoor Facility in Cincinnati on Tuesday, June 11, 2024. Credit: The Enquirer

Even with Joe Burrow having bounced back from the wrist injury that derailed his 2023 season, the Cincinnati Bengals find themselves 0-3 to open the 2024 campaign.

But while it’s the Bengals defense that has taken the bulk of the blame for Cincinnati’s 38-33 loss to the Washington Commanders on Monday night, one Hall of Fame player directed his ire at the team’s starting quarterback.

“He played well, not well enough to win,” Shannon Sharpe said of Burrow on Tuesday’s episode of ESPN’s First Take.

Sharpe’s statement — which came in agreement with previous comments made by former NFL defensive lineman Chris Canty — drew an immediate disagreement from Marcus Spears.

“I’m gonna be honest. I don’t want to live in a world where a quarterback throws for 330 and three touchdowns with no turnovers and we’re gonna say he didn’t do enough to win a football game,” a clearly disappointed Spears said. “I don’t want to live in that world in the NFL.”

“I do!” Sharpe responded. “You live in a world where they make $55 million. Why do they make so much if so much isn’t expected of them?”

People were interested in these podcasts
Play Episode
65min
The Play-By-Play
NBA ‘Face of the League’ talk, Trump controlling sports world, Cena turns heel
A discussion about who's the face of the NBA devolved into the usual NBA discourse. President Donald Trump is anywhere and everywhere in the sports world. John Cena shocked everyone by becoming a bad guy in WWE. Awful Announcing's Ben Axelrod and Brendon Kleen discuss these topics and more on the latest episode of The Play-By-Play.Time Stamps:-:37: NBA “Face of the League” talk fueling negative discourse-25:01: Donald Trump controlling the sports world-42:16: John Cena turns heel-54:27: NBA Centel disappeared and returned to X-1:00:21: Giving up X posting for LentYou can subscribe to The Play-By-Play wherever podcasts are found. Please subscribe, rate and review!Download The Play-By-Play:Listen on AppleListen on SpotifyAwful Announcing on XAwful Announcing on FacebookAwful Announcing on InstagramAwful Announcing on ThreadsAwful Announcing on BlueSkyAwful Announcing on LinkedIn Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
The Play-By-Play
A mega Tom Brady NFL announcing check in with Awful Announcing's Sean Keeley
Tom Brady is 13 weeks in his NFL broadcasting career, and did his first Thanksgiving game. How is Brady doing? Has he improved? How long will he continue broadcasting? Awful Announcing's Ben Axelrod, Brendon Kleen, and Sean Keeley discuss these topics and more on the latest episode of The Play-By-Play.Time Stamps:-1:18: Tom Brady on Thanksgiving Fox broadcast-30:28: Azeez Al-Shaair’s hit on Trevor Lawrence-40:03: Ryan Day and Ohio State-50:44: Matt Eberflus and the Chicago Bears-57:23: Stugotz’s new book-59:32: Kai Cenat’s Twitch subathon-1:03:58: Fran BrownYou can subscribe to The Play-By-Play wherever podcasts are found. Please subscribe, rate and review!Download The Play-By-Play:Listen on AppleListen on SpotifyAwful Announcing on XAwful Announcing on FacebookAwful Announcing on InstagramAwful Announcing on ThreadsAwful Announcing on BlueSkyAwful Announcing on LinkedIn Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
The Play-By-Play
Loving Dan Hurley, Shohei Ohtani 'Face of MLB,' Gen Z and sports
Dan Hurley rubs many the wrong way, so is that why he's great for college basketball? Is Shohei Ohtani the face of Major League Baseball. Are the lack of Cinderellas really what's destroying college basketball. Awful Announcing's Ben Axelrod and Brendon Kleen discuss these topics and more, including an in-depth discussion with Morning Consult's Ellyn Briggs on how Gen Z consumes sports, on the latest episode of The Play-By-Play.Time Stamps:-1:04: No Cinderellas in March Madness-21:11: Ellyn Briggs joins the show-21:39: Best way to summarize how Gen Z consumes sports-24:57: Gen Z having a strong connection to athletes, going to games-29:49: NIL and Gen Z-31:22: Sports going away from a made-for-TV product?-34:17: Gen Z and Gen-Alpha sports participation-37:13: Public reaction to Jackie Robinson article temporarily taken down-42:30: Women’s sports fans supporting activism among players-46:33: LIV Golf/Saudi Arabia and sportswashing-50:20: What has to happen for a new league to work in 2025?-54:48: Dan Hurley-57:48: Shohei Ohtani as the “Face of MLB”You can subscribe to The Play-By-Play wherever podcasts are found. Please subscribe, rate and review!Download The Play-By-Play:Listen on AppleListen on SpotifyAwful Announcing on XAwful Announcing on FacebookAwful Announcing on InstagramAwful Announcing on ThreadsAwful Announcing on BlueSkyAwful Announcing on LinkedIn Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
The Play-By-Play
Paul-Tyson Netflix fight issues, 'Inside the NBA' to ESPN
Netflix's tech issues made it difficult to watch the Jake Paul-Mike Tyson fight. "Inside the NBA" finds a new home. More people are heading to Bluesky. Awful Announcing's Ben Axelrod and Brendon Kleen discuss these topics and more on the latest episode of The Play-By-Play.Time Stamps:-1:23: Netflix’s tech issues during Jake Paul-Mike Tyson fight-18:22: NFL Christmas games being “make or break” for Netflix-22:10: “Inside the NBA” heads to ESPN-35:43: Winners and losers to the ESPN/“Inside the NBA” deal-51:21: People heading to Bluesky-1:00:47: Barstool hiring Jon Gruden-1:04:39: Wrestling Observer Hall of Fame announcementYou can subscribe to The Play-By-Play wherever podcasts are found. Please subscribe, rate and review!Download The Play-By-Play:Listen on AppleListen on SpotifyAwful Announcing on XAwful Announcing on FacebookAwful Announcing on InstagramAwful Announcing on ThreadsAwful Announcing on BlueSkyAwful Announcing on LinkedIn Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

While the Bengals didn’t win, it would be tough to point to Burrow as one of the primary reasons why. To Spears’ point, the 2019 Heisman Trophy winner completed 76.3 percent of his passes for 324 yards and three touchdowns, while it was Cincinnati’s defense that allowed 38 points in the defeat.

Still, considering his salary, Sharpe believes that it’s not unrealistic that Burrow should be expected to be “Superman” when he’s on the field. Meanwhile, Spears is having a hard time understanding why the Bengals’ defensive blunders should take away from what he believes was a superhero-like performance from the former LSU star.

“WHEN THE HELL IS THREE TOUCHDOWNS FOR 330 NOT SUPERMAN?!” Spears erupted. “Shay, he needed six touchdowns?”

[Awful Announcing]

About Ben Axelrod

Ben Axelrod is a veteran of the sports media landscape, having most recently worked for NBC's Cleveland affiliate, WKYC. Prior to his time in Cleveland, he covered Ohio State football and the Big Ten for outlets including Cox Media Group, Bleacher Report, Scout and Rivals.