Although their respective careers have since diverged into two completely different directions, it’s nearly impossible to think of Kenan Thompson and Kel Mitchell without recalling Nickelodeon sketch (and actually decent movie, no matter what Rotten Tomatoes says) Good Burger.

Thankfully, late night peddler of nineties nostalgia Jimmy Fallon was able to get both men together for a new sketch based on Good Burger with Kel returning as Ed. Sure, seeing Fallon insert himself into the sketch is a bit jarring (if predictable) but watching the Nickelodeon alums brush off the old sketch concept makes for a pretty great (as in rose-tinted nostalgic) time.

[The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon]