A Dallas Cowboys helmet Kirby Lee-USA TODAY Sports

The Dallas Cowboys surprised many when they opted to bring in Brian Schottenheimer as their next head coach heading into the 2025 NFL season. And much to the chagrin of Cowboys fans, Schottenheimer’s arrival likely means that a Cowboys legend will not be included in the Cowboys coaching staff.

One of the darkhorse head coaching candidates for the Cowboys throughout their hiring process was legendary tight end Jason Witten, who spent 16 seasons in Dallas and made 11 Pro Bowl appearances throughout his time with the team.

Since his retirement from the NFL, Witten has been a coach at the high school ranks, leading the Liberty Christian Warriors in Texas to back-to-back state championships in 2022 and 2023.

Though Witten has no NFL coaching experience to speak of, some believe that Witten would have been the perfect man to lead the Cowboys given the fact that he already has a working relationship with owner Jerry Jones.

Jones has even spoken quite highly of Witten’s coaching abilities, saying that he believes Witten will one day be an “excellent” NFL coach.

Despite this, Jerry Jones decided to go in another direction and hire Schottenheimer. And Schottenheimer does not appear to have any interest in bringing in Witten as an assistant.

People were interested in these podcasts
Play Episode
71min
The Play-By-Play
Drew Brees on ESPN, Dave Portnoy feuds with Zach Bryan, Chris Vannini joins us
Drew Brees makes a surprise appearance on "Monday Night Countdown." Dave Portnoy drops multiple diss tracks on Country music star Zach Bryan. Awful Announcing's Ben Axelrod and Brendon Kleen discuss these topics and more, as The Athletic's Chris Vannini joins us on the latest episode of The Play-By-Play.Time Stamps:-:54: Drew Brees shows up on “Monday Night Countdown”-20:31: Chris Vannini comes on The Play-By-Play-58:46: Dave Portnoy vs. Zach Bryan-1:04:26: Sports podcast monologuesYou can subscribe to The Play-By-Play wherever podcasts are found. Please subscribe, rate and review!Download The Play-By-Play:Listen on AppleListen on SpotifyAwful Announcing on XAwful Announcing on FacebookAwful Announcing on InstagramAwful Announcing on ThreadsAwful Announcing on BlueSkyAwful Announcing on LinkedIn Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
The Play-By-Play
Shannon Sharpe sex on IG Live, The Athletic pivoting, Jason Kelce all over ‘MNF’
Shannon Sharpe accidentally posting himself having sex on Instagram Live. Is a Pistons beat writer moving to cover the Knicks a sign of change for The Athletic? Was sports media being condescending toward Tua Tagovailoa? Awful Announcing's Brendon Kleen and Ben Axelrod discuss all that and more, including ESPN getting their money's worth for Jason Kelce this Monday night on the latest episode of The Play-By-Play.Time Stamps:-1:16: Shannon Sharpe having sex on Instagram Live-13:00: The Athletic pivoting away from local coverage?-27:31: Congress proposing sports gambling legislation-41:21: Pro athletes getting endorsement deals within sports betting companies-47:46: Jason Kelce was all over ESPN Monday night-51:25: Sports media conversation about Tua Tagovailoa’s concussionYou can subscribe to The Play-By-Play wherever podcasts are found. Please subscribe, rate and review! Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
The Play-By-Play
Stephen A. vs. LeBron, CBS makes big changes, Peter Schrager to ESPN
Stephen A. Smith and LeBron James going at it. Gary Danielson announces his retirement, resulting in CBS to make moves in their college football and NFL broadcasts. Peter Schrager leaves NFL Network for ESPN. Awful Announcing's Ben Axelrod and Brendon Kleen, along with AA head Ben Koo, discuss these topics and more on the latest episode of The Play-By-Play.Time Stamps:-:47: Stephen A. Smith vs. LeBron James-21:54: Gary Danielson retiring, Charles Davis replacing Danielson, JJ Watt replacing Davis at CBS-43:13: ESPN hires Peter Schrager-58:23: Zach Lowe joins The Ringer-59:56: RIP NFL Chain Gang-1:02:44: Dave Portnoy being the most influential person in the intersection of sports and politicsYou can subscribe to The Play-By-Play wherever podcasts are found. Please subscribe, rate and review!Download The Play-By-Play:Listen on AppleListen on SpotifyAwful Announcing on XAwful Announcing on FacebookAwful Announcing on InstagramAwful Announcing on ThreadsAwful Announcing on BlueSkyAwful Announcing on LinkedIn Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
The Play-By-Play
ESPN and MLB split, Jay Caspian Kang joins for Stephen A. Smith political talk
What is Stephen A. Smith's political endgame? The New Yorker's Jay Caspian King joins Awful Announcing's Ben Axelrod and Brendon Kleen to discuss. Ben and Brendon will also talk about ESPN opting out of their MLB contract after 2025, as well as various NBA topics including Richard Jefferson and Brian Windhorst on the latest episode of The Play-By-Play.Time Stamps:-2:04: ESPN opts out of MLB rights after 2025-20:36: View From the Subreddit: ESPN Edition-26:14: “Court of Gold”-39:02: The New Yorker’s Jay Caspian Kang joins to discuss Stephen A. Smith’s political aspirations-1:03:34: Richard Jefferson joining Mike Breen and Doris Burke on NBA Finals broadcast-1:07:23: Brian Windhorst a free agent after the NBA seasonYou can subscribe to The Play-By-Play wherever podcasts are found. Please subscribe, rate and review!Download The Play-By-Play:Listen on AppleListen on SpotifyAwful Announcing on XAwful Announcing on FacebookAwful Announcing on InstagramAwful Announcing on ThreadsAwful Announcing on BlueSkyAwful Announcing on LinkedIn Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

According to Jerry Jones, Witten is not expected to join his former team in any capacity this coming season, which was first reported on by Patrik Walker of the Cowboys team website.

Ideally, someone like Witten would end up as an NFL assistant before taking a head coaching job once he becomes a bit more polished as a coach.

Maybe that will happen in Dallas in years to come or potentially elsewhere around the NFL. But regardless, Witten is believed to be returning back to the high school coaching ranks for the time being.

About Reice Shipley

Reice Shipley is a staff writer for Comeback Media that graduated from Ithaca College with a degree in Sports Media. He previously worked at Barrett Sports Media and is a fan of all things Syracuse sports.