35. Lyle Overbay, First Baseman
Unlike Youkilis, Overbay turned out to be a godsend for the Yankees, as injuries limited incumbent first baseman Mark Teixiera to only 15 games in 2013. Overbay hit 14 home runs with 51 RBIs and even served as the clean up hitter for the Yanks at times this past season. If anything, his 2013 campaign showed that he can still cut it in the major leagues and earned himself another big league contract.
