I am no expert in determining one’s weight purely by looking at them, however in this instance I believe I have a point. @Jose3030 pointed out on Twitter that one of the entries on ESPN may be off regarding MLB players. Notice the below ESPN Player Page in which a certain NY Yankees pitcher is listed as weighing in at 185lbs. Does that seem like it may be 5lbs off or so to you as well?
Now tell me, does that look like the face and upper body of someone who weighs 185lbs?